It’s not his fault. You know that.
HE’S PLEADING “HICCUP” IN THE SECOND TO LAST GIF OH MY GOD MY HEART MY HEART MY HEART IS DEAD.
I never noticed Astrid in that first little bit, but her face as she glances between them becomes so concerned and sadder about what’s happening. Astrid already knew it wasn’t Toothless’ fault Valka doesn’t seem as shocked by it, and Gobber is just out but Astrid gets how bad this is, how sad this is.